Manero's of Mulberry Reviews

Delicious Slice! I had pizza at 3 different places while in NYC for the first time, and this was the best. You can taste the quality of great cheeses in their pizza, and the crust was perfect.

The pizza was amazing—so good that we had to go back before leaving and will absolutely return on our next trip to New York. It’s a small shop with limited standing room (about 3–4 people at a window shelf), but it’s 100% worth it even if you have to step outside to eat. Also, a little piece of Saturday Night Fever filming history. Service is fast, and the location is great—close to shopping, the subway, and other restaurants in Little Italy.

Great crust and sauce. Loved it. From New Haven Ct home of Pepe’s, Modern and Sally’s. Manero’s was equal to those.

Restaurant prices in NYC are high because of the enormous rent they pay. We were shocked when we found this little place on Mulberry. We each had a slice of pizza for $3 a slice. Soft drinks were $2 a can. The pizza crust was homemade. There were types of pizza (for instance, they didn't have pepperoni pizza on display). The slices were large and tasty. We really enjoyed it. There were other larger, fancier places on Mulberry (much pricier), but we were glad we found Manero's. They were fast, and the food was good. We enjoyed it.

Whe where looking for a good street pizza in NY, and found this place in the middle of Little Italy. Incredible pizza at a great price! Ah, and great service!

The guy behind the counter was quick. I tried a Slice of their plain pizza and a can of the Brooklyn’s best peach tea. So good. You could see the fresh garlic slices on the pizza. There is a sitting area outside on the beautiful day.

Manero's Pizza must be new because I had never seen the place before. It has a very limited menu but I have to say the pizzas they offer are just excellent. I had a slice of the Marinara with fresh mozzarella and it was heaven. The sauce is made with the freshest tomatoes and it was well spiced and you could just taste the tomatoes. Just out of the garden. The regular pizza with the same fresh tomato sauce and shredded mozzarella was just as good. You could taste the rich tomato sauce in every bite. The best part is the dough. It is puffy on the inside and crisp on the outside and has the taste from the brick oven. It was so perfectly cooked. The best part was the slices were $3.00 which was very fair for the quality. The service was also very good as the gentleman making the pizzas could not have been nicer. I want to warn you that they are credit only which I prefer. Don't miss this excellent pizzeria in Little Italy.

We stopped for a quick bite before China town and Little Italy and we were not disappointed. The crust was terrific. The slices were $3 & $4 plus toppings. Really hit the spot. We recommend it highly!

My 22-year-old son found this single-slice pizza place in Little Italy. Reasonably priced. There's nowhere to sit inside as the space is very small. At first, I was skeptical, but at first bite, I knew it was. a winner. Thin, crispy crust, with a slightly chewy center, with just the right touch of marinara and cheese. During our visit, we made a number of visits back to Manero's.

I have been to Manero's pizza several times and no matter what type of pizza you order here it is excellent. I have had the traditional and Cheese slices before and they were excellent. Today I had the Sicilian slice with fresh mozzarella and it was excellent. The bottom and outside were nice and crisp and the the topping is made with slices of fresh mozzarella and their freshly made tomato sauce. The sauce has so much flavor and is so well spiced that you can really taste the tomatoes in each bite. It is like biting into a piece of crisp flatbread. The service is really good and the guy who works the counter is so welcoming and helpful. What is also nice is that there is a small area for outside dining in the warmer weather. It is nice to just sit outside and people watch in Little Italy.

Great slice for a decent price. Would have given 5 stars if more veggie options. Overall tasty pizza in the heart of Little Italy.

This is the third time I have visited Manero's Pizza and the pizza consistently is excellent. The sauce has an amazing flavor to it and the pizza itself is crisp on the bottom and in the crust and pillowy when you bite into the crust. The wood oven gives it that nice texture. They use such a high quality of cheese on both the regular cheese pizza and the Margarita that the flavor is wonderful. What is nice is the price is very fair for a slice and the size of their slices are very generous. Because of COVID, they have outside tables to dine at and on a very unusual 55 degree December night, I was able to eat outside and enjoy my dinner without freezing. The service is always very nice and professional.

We grabbed a nice slice of pesto pizza with great crust, flavor, and cheese for $4. Perfect snack shared with my wife and we both loved it.

We were walking around Mulberry and decided to stop at Manero's for a slice of pizza. Friendly staff and tasty slice. Highly recommend!

Stopped for a slice of pizza here on the way to the airport following our cruise. This was an amazing slice of pizza that I would thoroughly recommend at a very reasonable price. Give it a go you won't be disappointed.

We were back in NYC for a family wedding, having relocated to the midwest decades earlier. Each time we return, NY pizza is one of the things on our must-do list. As we were enjoying walking around Little Italy, still full from an earlier family brunch, we stumbled upon Manero's. All we had to do was peek inside and enjoy the oven's aroma wafting outside when the door opened, and we knew that this had to be our NY pizza experience for this visit. We made it nice and simple and ordered a few slices of plain pizza. As a pizza purist, I find that this is the best way to truly judge a good pizza. Manero's crust, sauce, and cheese were perfect. We were some very happy campers as we sat out on nearby steps to dine. The next time we're back, we'll definitely make sure we arrive at Manero's with an enormous appetite. The garlic knots looked insanely delicious, too!

Great pizza with the family. Sitting just in the South end of Little Italy on Mulberry St., this little gem won't disappoint. Decent service, nothing fancy, but great food. They recommend trying Mike's Hot Honey on our pizza and it blew my mind! Thanks!

This place definitely deserves more recognition! The best pizza that we had in NYC, can’t recommend enough - so good!!!

I had a slice of the pesto margarita and it was delicious. Nice staff, and there are a couple of benches outside to sit and eat.

I live in Europe and have had a lot of pizza in a lot of countries, including the "real" Italy. My personal favorite is still a Pizzeria in Rome that I had the pleasure of dining in several years ago. But Monero's managed to make it into my personal Top 10.

Hugh, yummi Pizza. During our stay in NYC July 2022 we ate dinner here. The pizza was hugh!! Please see photo. My daughter had pasta which was also deliscious. The price was more than fair.