Mia’s Brooklyn Bakery Reviews

The sheer range of products is slowly discovered sd you sit there. I just had plain hot chocolate, but it was delicious. Together with the apple bread pudding it was perfect. As I sat I observed the display and was just wowed.

Amazing desserts! We ordered a few different cupcakes, an Oreo cheesecake and carrot cake slice and were some of the best we have had. Very friendly as well and easy to get to! It’s right next to the renaissance hotel entrance!

My friends from NY have been raving about this place so I decided to try it out. Got a Sprinkle cookie, strawberry shortcake, and a croissant to go! I enjoyed the cake most but the others, nothing special. Croissant was a brick by the time I ate in the morning. Easily dropped $22. The workers were so nice and welcoming. Maybe I’ll give the other pastries a taste next time.

OMG… I can’t even put words to describe how good the cake is, the icing was so smooth it was like silk and the cake was so soft and fully, it melted in my mouth like a fluffy cloud

We had 3 pieces of cake delivered to our hotel. The red velvet was amazing- best I ever had. The nutella cake was just as good and my daughter loved it. The rainbow cake looked great but I didnt care for it- it was good just not my taste.

This place was a wonderful find in Times Square! They don’t have much signage outside and only noticed it as we walked by. We got a bunch of macaroons, which were delicious! I also got the Gluten Free Panna Cotta. I’m not a gluten free person but the desert looked so pretty that I wanted to try it, it was outstanding! Much better than the Cake Boss bakery cupcake I had the day prior!

Best baked goods if had in a long time. Big variety for a small shop. No place to sit and eat, but we grabbed them on the way to Central Park and ate there.

Discovered this bakery late one night only to discover it was still open. We treated ourselves to a salted caramel cupcake and tres leche cupcake! OMG! These were the best I have ever had! The salted caramel was a perfect balance…not too sweet! The tres leche was out of this world.

We stopped in here for something sweet before seeing a show. I had a chocolate almond croissant that was very good, my daughter had a piece of blueberry topped cheese cake and said it was the best she had ever had (she loves cheesecake) and my mom had a custard filled lobster tail. We all really enjoyed our choices, only regret we couldn’t try more!

I visited the Times Square location and ordered 4 macaroons. I gave my credit card to my daughter to pay for them. It was a beautiful day in NYC so we decided to wait and eat them outside. Upon looking at my receipt, I noticed that I was also charged $5.00 for a cannoli, which we did not order nor receive. Mistakes due happen, but we were the only ones in the store so there were no other distractions. Lesson learned- always check your receipt! Macaroons were good though!

We wanted to try New York cheesecake and Mia’s looked interesting. There was so much choice but we opted for the Oriol cheesecake and the chocolate fudge cake. What can I say, both were fantastic but the cheesecake was superb. So good that we returned the following night and got some more (and strawberry and strawberry shortcake which were both also amazing)

Amazing choice. Tried an oreo cupcake and a ginger cookie, both were really nice but the cookie was better!

Went with family for coffee and dessert after dinner 6/19/21 and had Black Forest Cake. Great Service and Cake. Would definitely go again!

We almost missed this place with the huge crowds and it’s diminutive storefront. It doesn’t hold many people and feels like you are in a closet—with a lot of people. That being said the chocolate cheesecake was actually pretty good and not as sweet as Junior’s. At $8.75 a slice that seemed reasonable for NYC.

Came across this bakery and I am so happy I did! Making a decision was tough, but I settled in a ginger cookie, chocolate chip cookie, and a cannookie. All were amazing, I loved the cannookie, but the chocolate chip cookie was seriously the best I’ve ever had and I’ve had a lot since it’s my favorite!!

Wanting to experience the lauded macaron for the first time, we tried several bakeries around Manhattan and these were our favorite.

Never had worse cake before trying Mia”s cake. The cake was dry and tasteless, you can find better cake than this at a grocery store

I went to Mia’s in Times Square. I’m celiac and they offered gluten free desserts. I had the chocolate mousse cake. It’s was ok. Very dense. There was no need for the sprinkles around the outside. It tasted like it was in the fridge for a little while. It was just ok.

had the most fabulous piece of cheesecake i’ve ever had here. no piece of cheesecake has topped it to date for me personally.

Coconut cake was to die for!!! The slice was so big i couldn’t finish it…and that is saying a lot for me! Super convenient location too!

Was looking forward to going to Mia's to try my 1st lobster tail. I ordered the tail along with several items both times that I went. Both times they forgot to add one of my items. The lobster tail was chewy instead of flaky. I love flaky so was a little disappointed. The cream was good but a little bland. They had a good variety of items all beautiful to look at. I love these types of bakeries but we don't have many in the Midwest. New York is full of them. Didn't make it to Ferarra's which was on my bucket list. Will give them a try next time.

Outstanding choice and taste! As vegan travelers, we often struggle to find delectable options for dessert. Mia’s in Times Square came through BIG for us! Lovely!

We had the strawberry shortcake and the rainbow cake. They were so good! The most difficult thing is making a selection. This place is to-go only—it’s just a tiny place with a display case. Be sure to ask for forks. And be prepared to pay a lot, albeit for very good cake.

We had a hard time deciding what to get because EVERYTHING looked good! We ended up getting a couple meat and cheese breakfast croissants and the caramel cronut, which were outstanding! A must-visit!

I wanted a cupcake one evening. I had seen this bakery in my walking around and went back to it. The cupcake was very dry and not much flavor. I will not go back for sure.

Outstanding variety of delicious moist cakes n desserts. Friendly service too. You won’t be disappointed with any selection. I tried chocolate mousse, chocolate fudge, and chocolate cheesecake.

We stopped in to buy a piece of cake to take home to a friend. She loves the Napoleon cake from Mia's. The gentleman who helped us was so nice and packaged the cake with extra care for travel. Our friend said the cake was wonderful! My wife got a lobster tail pastry while we were there, and she said it was also outstanding. There are many bakeries near Times Square, of course. But we were really impressed with the quality, selection and friendly service provided by Mia's. We will definitely be back on our next NYC trip, and I highly recommend them.