Johnson's Shut-Ins, MO vs Hot Springs, Arkansas

Question

Looking for a place to stop/camp for 2 nights on a road trip from Chicago to Big Bend Nat'l Park, in early March of this year. Both are similar amounts of detour, so I was wondering which one was a more interesting site, for someone who has never been to the Ozarks before.

Answer

Both Johnson’s Shut-Ins State Park in Missouri and Hot Springs, Arkansas are interesting stops for a road trip through the Ozarks, but they offer quite different experiences. Choosing between them depends on what type of scenery and activities you’re most interested in.

Johnson’s Shut-Ins State Park, Missouri:

This park is known for its unique geological formations where the East Fork of the Black River flows through hard volcanic rock, creating natural “shut-ins” or water pools. It’s a classic Ozark experience and offers a more rugged, outdoor adventure vibe. Early March will be less crowded, but water may be cold, and swimming is unlikely at that time.

Scenic rock formations and hiking trails.
Camping options with cabins and campsites within the park.
Opportunities for photography, short hikes, and exploring natural pools.
Less commercialized, giving a true Ozarks nature experience.

Hot Springs, Arkansas:

Hot Springs is more of a historic town with natural hot springs, bathhouses, and a national park surrounding the town. It combines outdoor activities with cultural and historical experiences, making it a more town-centered stop rather than purely nature-focused.

Historic bathhouses and spa experiences using natural hot springs.
Hiking and scenic trails in Hot Springs National Park.
Restaurants, shops, and a charming small-town atmosphere.
More amenities and options for dining and relaxing after a long drive.

Considerations for your trip:

If you want a pure nature/Ozarks experience with rugged beauty and hiking, Johnson’s Shut-Ins is the better choice.
If you prefer a mix of relaxation, history, and light outdoor activities with more town amenities, Hot Springs offers a richer visitor infrastructure.
Early March weather can still be chilly in both areas, so check forecasts and pack layers. Some water features at Johnson’s Shut-Ins may be partially frozen or inaccessible.
Both locations have campgrounds, but Johnson’s Shut-Ins gives a more immersive camping experience, while Hot Springs may encourage staying in a hotel or inn with easier access to town facilities.

Overall, for a first-time visitor to the Ozarks who wants to see the natural landscape and geological features, Johnson’s Shut-Ins is likely the more unique and memorable stop. Hot Springs is excellent if you prefer a mix of natural beauty, history, and easy comforts.