Busy?

Question

May have a lead on a rental on Sanibel for the end of March. Wondering how busy it will be at that time? I know the last few years have been upended in the rental market, now with things coming together is it crazy busy?

Answer

Late March on Sanibel Island is typically one of the busiest times of the entire year. This period falls right in the heart of peak season, when weather is warm, humidity is still low, and spring break travelers—families, retirees, and longtime seasonal visitors—are all on the island at once. Historically, accommodations book up months in advance, and beaches, restaurants, and bike paths all see noticeably higher activity.

In recent years, the rental market was disrupted due to the impacts of Hurricane Ian, but as more properties reopen and the island continues rebuilding, demand has surged again. This means that even though not everything is back to 100%, the places that are available often fill up quickly. The good news is that the atmosphere remains relaxed compared to more commercialized destinations, even during busy stretches.

What you can generally expect at the end of March includes:

Very high occupancy rates for condos, cottages, and homes—booking early is essential.
More people on the beaches, especially near public access points, though Sanibel’s long shoreline helps spread visitors out.
Busier restaurants, often requiring waits at peak dinner hours.
Heavier traffic on Periwinkle Way, particularly midday and late afternoon.

Despite the crowds, many travelers find the experience enjoyable because Sanibel maintains a calm, nature-forward vibe. Even during peak times, you won’t see large party crowds—just families, shell-seekers, cyclists, and longtime snowbirds. March also brings excellent shelling conditions and beautiful weather, with warm days and cooler evenings.

If your priority is peaceful beaches and less congestion, you can still enjoy a quieter experience by planning strategically.

Visit beaches early in the morning or close to sunset.
Explore less-trafficked spots such as Bowman’s Beach or Gulfside City Park.
Biking instead of driving can help avoid the busiest road stretches.

Overall, yes—late March is busy, but in a pleasant, seasonal way that many visitors look forward to each year. If you have a good rental lead, it’s generally wise to secure it, as inventory for that timeframe tends to disappear quickly.

You’ll likely find the island lively but still relaxing, with plenty of natural beauty and a welcoming atmosphere even during peak season.