Where to stay????

Question

I've read all the forums and now most likely I just have myself all confused by too much info! I need help deciding where to stay in September for 9-10 days. Here's some info on me and my husband:

We are in our mid to late 50s, active and in reasonable shape. We like to hike (no hard trails) and recreational biking but also love to relax by the pool and beach. We are big bourbon drinkers and love a good cocktail in the evening as well as some nice meals out. Also love trying local foods/specialties, etc. This will be our second island to visit in Hawaii (traveled to Oahu several years ago). We are open to a resort or condo, but must have A/C. Would love to be right on a beach or within walking distance to a nice one. Also, looking to go on Napali boat tour. We are renting a car for sightseeing so that's not an issue. Please help me decide whether north shore or south shore would suit our needs better and if you have a recommendation for a place to stay. Thank you!!!!

Answer

For a 9-10 day stay in Kauai in September, both the North Shore and South Shore have distinct advantages depending on your priorities. Since you’re looking for a mix of gentle hikes, recreational biking, relaxation on the beach, nice cocktails, local food, and Napali boat tours, here’s a breakdown:

The North Shore (around Hanalei, Princeville, and Kilauea) is lush, scenic, and quieter than the South Shore. It offers:

Beautiful beaches like Hanalei Bay, ideal for gentle swimming and relaxing.
Access to Napali Coast boat tours departing from Hanalei or nearby harbors.
Charming small towns with boutique restaurants, craft cocktail bars, and local specialties.
Lots of easy to moderate hiking, especially around Hanalei Valley and Limahuli Garden trails.
A cooler, more tropical atmosphere with dramatic scenery and waterfalls.

The South Shore (Poipu, Koloa) is sunnier and drier, which is excellent for more predictable beach days. It features:

Beaches like Poipu Beach, ideal for swimming, snorkeling, and gentle walks.
Resorts and condos with A/C, easy access to pools, beachside relaxation, and fine dining with cocktail options.
More restaurants, bars, and tourist amenities within walking distance of resorts.
Good starting point for boat tours to Napali from Port Allen.
Plenty of beginner-friendly biking and easy hikes in nearby areas like Maha’ulepu Heritage Trail.

Considering your interests—relaxing with beach access, nice cocktails, moderate activity, and Napali tours—both shores work, but they offer slightly different vibes. If you prefer a laid-back, scenic, and slightly more local feel, the North Shore is ideal. If you want sun, convenience, and more resort-style amenities, the South Shore is more practical.

Recommended places to stay with A/C and beach access:

North Shore: Hanalei Bay Resort, Princeville at Hanalei condos, or small boutique vacation rentals along Hanalei Bay.
South Shore: Grand Hyatt Kauai Resort & Spa, Koloa Landing Resort at Poipu, or Poipu Shores condos for oceanfront access and pool amenities.

Tips for your trip:

Napali boat tours often depart in the morning; book in advance for best availability and weather conditions.
For cocktails and local dining, Poipu has more options conveniently clustered near resorts, whereas the North Shore may require a short drive.
Bring light layers for hiking and early morning or sunset activities, as temperatures can vary.
Recreational biking can be done along coastal roads on either shore, but Poipu has flatter, more accessible routes.

In summary, for a balance of relaxation, gentle adventure, and local food & drinks, the South Shore may be slightly more convenient, but the North Shore offers unmatched scenic beauty and a tranquil Hawaiian vibe. Both areas have great options for A/C accommodations right on or near the beach.

Where to stay????

More Kauai Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions