Uber vs private driver

Question

Hello! We are traveling to St.Helena in June. We are have our vineyards selected, but we are trying to decide on transportation. We are thinking about a few possibilities.

1. Hiring a private driver

2. Using uber/lyft to get around

Does anyone have any suggestions on what is better? Since we don’t need guidance on vineyards, I’m not sure if a private driver is necessary? It looks like in previous reviews uber is pretty reliable.

If we do go the driver route, are there any companies you recommend?

Answer

For traveling around St. Helena and the Napa Valley, both Uber/Lyft and private drivers are viable options, but they each have pros and cons depending on your group’s preferences, schedule, and comfort level with planning.

Option 1: Uber or Lyft

Uber and Lyft are generally reliable in the Napa Valley, especially in the main towns like St. Helena, Yountville, and Napa city.
They offer flexibility—you can request rides only when needed and avoid paying for a full-day driver.
Pricing can fluctuate, particularly during busy weekends, harvest season, or peak hours, so expect fares to sometimes be higher than anticipated.
Wait times may vary, especially in less populated areas or between vineyards in rural spots, so plan ahead to avoid delays.
Good choice if your group is comfortable managing timing and doesn’t mind coordinating pickups between vineyards.

Option 2: Private Driver

Hiring a private driver offers convenience and peace of mind. They can pick you up and drop you off between all your selected vineyards, often with minimal wait.
You can customize your schedule, avoid surge pricing, and have someone familiar with local roads, traffic, and winery parking.
Private drivers can provide a more relaxed experience, especially if your group prefers not to worry about app availability or coordinating rides in rural areas.
Pricing is higher than Uber/Lyft, usually quoted as a half-day or full-day rate, but it can be worth it for comfort, flexibility, and efficiency.
Recommended companies in the Napa Valley include:

Napa Valley Wine Country Limo
Beau Wine Tours
Pure Luxury Transportation Napa
Napa Valley Chauffeur

Recommendation

If your itinerary is tightly scheduled, involves multiple vineyards with short windows, or you prefer a stress-free day, a private driver is likely the better choice. If you’re only visiting a few wineries and are comfortable coordinating timing, Uber or Lyft is a cost-effective and flexible option. Many visitors combine approaches—using Uber for short hops in town and hiring a driver for the full-day vineyard experience.

Uber vs private driver

More St. Helena Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions