chicago pizza

Question

Coming to Chicago this weekend and while we have reservations each night already for some fabulous looking restaurants, we want to grab some pizza for lunch one day. I've been searching and can't find an answer, so now I'm here. Is there a pizza place that serves both stuffed and deep dish pizzas? We have some in our group that want one kind and some the other. If not, what is your favorite stuffed pizza place to go to? Thanks in advance everyone! (PS, I did find the Art of Pizza that does both, but apparently it's reheated and not fresh, so that is not appealing to me.)

Answer

Chicago is famous for its iconic deep dish and stuffed pizzas, and it's understandable that you're looking for a place where you can enjoy both types of pizza fresh and hot! While many pizzerias specialize in one or the other, there are a few places that offer both deep dish and stuffed pizza options, and they’re known for making them fresh to order. Here are some of the best options for you:

1. Pizano's Pizza & Pasta
Pizano’s is a local favorite and is known for serving both stuffed and deep dish pizzas. It's a family-owned pizzeria that makes its dough fresh, and they are known for their delicious thin crust, as well as the deep dish and stuffed pizzas. It's a great spot if you have people in your group wanting different styles of pizza, and it’s made fresh, not reheated like some other places.

Stuffed Pizza: Their stuffed pizza is classic, with a buttery, flaky crust and lots of cheese and toppings.
Deep Dish Pizza: Known for its hearty, cheesy deep dish, Pizano’s offers a satisfying version with a thick crust and rich tomato sauce.

2. Labriola Chicago
Labriola is another fantastic spot offering both deep dish and stuffed pizza. Their deep dish is often recommended for its perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and crust, while their stuffed pizza is made with a generous amount of cheese and fillings. They also offer a range of other menu items if you’re looking for more variety.

Stuffed Pizza: Labriola’s stuffed pizza is made with layers of mozzarella cheese and delicious toppings, all encased in their signature dough.
Deep Dish Pizza: Their deep dish pizza features a crispy, buttery crust and is filled with the classic ingredients of a Chicago deep dish pizza.

3. Bartoli’s Pizzeria
Bartoli’s is a well-loved family-run spot in the city that offers both stuffed and deep dish pizzas. They’re particularly known for their fresh ingredients and homemade crust. While their deep dish pizza is delicious, their stuffed pizza is definitely worth trying, with a thicker crust and more of a “pie” feel to it. It’s a great choice for anyone looking for a true Chicago pizza experience.

Stuffed Pizza: Known for its deep, flaky crust, filled with gooey cheese, meats, and veggies.
Deep Dish Pizza: Bartoli’s deep dish is rich, cheesy, and has a savory tomato sauce with a crispy crust.

4. Giordano's
While Giordano’s is famous for its stuffed pizza, it also serves deep dish pizza, so it could be a good place to check out for your group. They are known for their stuffed deep dish pizza, which is essentially a hybrid of the two styles. Their stuffed pizza is baked with a thicker crust and more cheese, and while they don’t have a wide selection of styles, their pizzas are solid and satisfy most cravings for Chicago-style pizza.

Stuffed Pizza: Their stuffed pizza is legendary, with layers of cheese, sauce, and toppings all baked inside a golden crust.
Deep Dish Pizza: Their deep dish features a buttery crust with plenty of sauce and cheese, often served in a pan-style with more toppings.

5. The Art of Pizza
Although you mentioned Art of Pizza, it’s worth noting that they do offer fresh stuffed and deep dish pizzas, unlike the reheated versions some people claim to get. If you decide to give it a try, it might be best to call ahead to ensure you’re getting a freshly made pizza. Their deep dish is hearty, and their stuffed pizza has an excellent crust and plenty of cheese, making it a great place if you want both styles in one spot.

If you're after the best fresh options, I’d suggest trying Pizano’s or Labriola, as they’re known for their made-to-order stuffed and deep dish pizzas. Enjoy your trip and happy pizza eating!

chicago pizza

More Chicago Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions