help choosing a la jolla hotel

Question

I’m trying to decide between three great hotels and could use some input. I’m looking for an upscale hotel with beautiful rooms and a prime location. I know it’s a good problem to have, but I’m torn between the Valencia Hotel, the Grande Colonial, and the Inn by the Sea. Price isn’t a concern. Ideally, I’d like a hotel with a restaurant offering room service, but that’s not a deal-breaker.

I like the casual vibe of the Inn by the Sea, and although the Valencia and Grande Colonial seem more upscale, I don't know if they might feel too stuffy or “scene-y” . Any thoughts or recommendations based on your experiences would be much appreciated!

Answer

All three hotels in La Jolla you are considering—Valencia Hotel, Grande Colonial, and Inn by the Sea—are excellent choices, each with its own character and advantages. Here’s a detailed breakdown to help you decide:

The Valencia Hotel is modern and stylish, with a boutique feel. It has well-appointed rooms and a central location near shops and restaurants. The vibe is upscale but not overly formal, making it comfortable for a relaxing stay while still feeling luxurious.

The Grande Colonial is the most historic and traditionally upscale of the three. Its rooms are elegant and classic, with many featuring ocean views. The hotel has a refined ambiance and a formal dining option, which adds a sense of luxury. However, it can feel a bit more “scene-y” with its popular lobby and events, so if you prefer a quieter, low-key environment, this might be a consideration.

The Inn by the Sea has a more casual, intimate, and relaxed vibe. It is well-suited if you prefer a cozy atmosphere over polished grandeur. The rooms are comfortable and charming, and while the hotel may not have the extensive restaurant options of the other two, it does emphasize a more personal and laid-back experience.

If you want modern luxury with a boutique feel: Valencia Hotel.
If you want classic elegance and don’t mind a bit of a bustling atmosphere: Grande Colonial.
If you want a casual, cozy, and intimate stay: Inn by the Sea.

Other factors to consider include proximity to the beach and walkability. All three hotels are within reasonable distance of the main La Jolla Village area. The Valencia and Grande Colonial are slightly closer to central restaurants and shopping, whereas the Inn by the Sea feels more tucked away, which may appeal if you prefer tranquility.

Room service is available at Valencia and Grande Colonial; Inn by the Sea may have more limited options.
Valencia has a rooftop area and modern amenities, making it attractive for photography or casual socializing.
Grande Colonial has historic charm and might be more photogenic if you enjoy classic architecture.

Overall, if you’re seeking a balance of upscale comfort, accessibility, and not too formal, the Valencia Hotel might be the best fit. If you prioritize historic luxury and don’t mind a livelier scene, go with the Grande Colonial. For a casual and intimate stay with a cozy feel, the Inn by the Sea is ideal.

help choosing a la jolla hotel

More La Jolla Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions