I’m in the beginning stages of planning a trip for 3 adults. We will be driving to the redwoods from Crater Lake (via Oregon Caves if they reopen tours) and then will have 2 full days (a Friday and Saturday in August) to explore before heading up the southern Oregon coast. Would you go to Jedidiah Smith or Prairie Creek or one day in each? We can do short hikes (5 ish miles or less) and scenic drives. I see advice to stay in Trinidad over Crescent City but am mostly concerned with a safe/clean place to sleep - otherwise we’ll be out exploring. Thoughts?
With two full days in the Redwoods after coming from Crater Lake, you can absolutely see the highlights without feeling rushed. Since you enjoy short hikes and scenic drives, the best plan is to spend one day in Jedediah Smith Redwoods and one day in Prairie Creek Redwoods. These two areas offer the most spectacular old-growth redwoods in the entire region, and they each have a distinct personality that makes visiting both worthwhile.
Jedediah Smith (near Crescent City) is wilder, more intimate, and has some of the densest, most impressive old-growth groves anywhere. Prairie Creek, farther south near Orick, is iconic “Jurassic Park” style redwoods with meadows, elk, fern canyons, and multiple easy trails. Together they make the perfect two-day sampler.
As for lodging, Trinidad is generally more scenic, quieter, and offers higher-quality stays than Crescent City. Crescent City is convenient for Jedediah Smith but tends to be more basic. If your priority is simply a clean, safe place to sleep and you’ll be out exploring all day, you could stay in either — Trinidad is nicer overall, Crescent City is more practical for early starts.
Here is how I would plan your two full days:
Day 1 — Jedediah Smith Redwoods State Park (near Crescent City)
Day 2 — Prairie Creek Redwoods State Park
If you want to stretch the trip a bit, Prairie Creek also pairs beautifully with heading up the southern Oregon coast afterward — the transition from giant trees to rugged beaches is one of the most beautiful drives in the Pacific Northwest.
In summary, visit both Jedediah Smith and Prairie Creek, stay in Trinidad if comfort matters most, or split nights if you want super quick access. You’ll get two days of world-class forests, scenic drives, and hikes that fit perfectly within your 5-mile range.