Hamilton-Turner Inn, Marshall House or elsewhere?

Question

Hello,

We are visiting Savannah for the first time later this year from the UK and I am looking at Marshall House’s one bedroom suites which seem to be priced quite reasonably (about $330 a night). I’ve since seen Hamilton-Turner Inn which looks to be quite a bit more upscale - it is about $370 a night for a two double room but seems to have a nicer breakfast. I’m now not sure where to stay - any advice you can offer on which is better in terms of location, rooms, food, etc would be greatly appreciated. Alternatively if there are any other good options in the area (we are looking for historic hotels with some character) I would really appreciate those suggestions too.

Many thanks!

Answer

Both the Marshall House and Hamilton-Turner Inn are excellent choices for a first-time visit to Savannah, and each offers a different experience in terms of history, location, and amenities. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide, along with some alternative historic options.

Marshall House:

Located on Broughton Street, right in the heart of the Historic District. Excellent for shopping, dining, and walking to squares.
The hotel has a long history dating back to 1851 and was used as a hospital during the Civil War. It retains historic charm, though rooms are modernized and functional rather than luxurious.
One-bedroom suites are reasonably priced, making it a good value for the location. Rooms are comfortable, though some may be smaller and more traditional in layout.
Breakfast is not included in the standard room rate, and dining options are limited compared to upscale inns.

Hamilton-Turner Inn:

Located on Lafayette Square, one of Savannah’s most scenic and historic squares, giving it a quieter and more residential feel while still very central.
This inn is more upscale, with beautifully decorated rooms, modern amenities, and attention to historic detail.
Breakfast is included and highly regarded, often featuring a full Southern-style spread with fresh ingredients.
The inn offers a more luxurious, intimate experience, with fewer rooms and a boutique feel, ideal if you want a quieter, romantic stay with character.

Alternative Historic Hotels in the Area:

The Gastonian: Boutique B&B on a historic square, offering a very intimate experience with luxurious rooms and breakfast included. Known for charm and excellent service.
Perry Lane Hotel: A more modern boutique hotel with historic-inspired decor, rooftop bar, and central location in the Historic District.
Kehoe House: Classic Savannah mansion converted to an inn, offering historic elegance, cozy rooms, and gourmet breakfast.

In summary, if your priority is central location, convenience, and value, Marshall House is a solid choice. If you prefer a more upscale, intimate experience with included breakfast and historic charm, Hamilton-Turner Inn is worth the slightly higher price. Alternative boutique historic inns like The Gastonian or Kehoe House offer similar character with a focus on a quiet, romantic stay. For a first-time visit, any of these options will provide easy walking access to squares, River Street, and key attractions.