Where did all the gays go?

Question

Brit here. First time back in KW since the 90s. Felt very gay then. But not now. Did they move without telling me? Depressing.

Answer

Key West has long been known as a vibrant LGBTQ+ destination, but the scene has evolved significantly since the 1990s. While it may feel different if you haven’t visited in decades, the gay community is still very present, though there are several factors that have changed the atmosphere.

Here are some reasons why Key West might feel less “gay-centric” compared to past decades:

Gentrification and rising costs: Real estate prices and vacation rental costs have increased dramatically, which has pushed some longtime residents and business owners out of the historic gay neighborhoods. This has changed the demographic mix of the island.
Tourism diversification: Key West has broadened its appeal to a wide range of visitors, including families and general tourists. Areas that were once exclusively gay-friendly now host a more mixed crowd, which can dilute the visible gay nightlife.
Shift in nightlife locations: Some iconic gay bars or clubs have closed, relocated, or changed ownership, while others cater to a broader audience. While Duval Street still has LGBTQ+ venues, some of the old haunts from the 90s are no longer operating.
Online socializing and events: Many LGBTQ+ travelers now find community through apps and events rather than just bars. Special events, Pride celebrations, and cruise-related gatherings remain strong, but day-to-day visibility on the street may be less noticeable.

Where you can still find a lively gay scene in Key West:

Duval Street: Many bars and clubs remain gay-friendly, including Aqua Nightclub, 801 Bourbon Bar, and Bourbon Street Pub. Even with a more mixed crowd, they continue to host drag shows, themed nights, and dance events.
White Street and near the historic seaport: A few smaller LGBTQ+ bars and cafés cater to the community in a slightly quieter setting.
Events and festivals: Key West Pride, Fantasy Fest, and other seasonal LGBTQ+ events still draw large crowds and are a great way to reconnect with the community.

In short, the gay presence in Key West hasn’t disappeared, but economic and demographic shifts have made it less concentrated than in the 90s. The community remains vibrant, but it’s now interwoven with broader tourism, which may feel different to longtime visitors.

Where did all the gays go?

More Key West Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions