Key Largo lodging - three nights late April

Question

As part of a Miami to Key West trip, we're going to stay in Key Largo for three nights. I'd like to be someplace with a pool, beach activities (like paddleboards) and close to a few restaurants. Budget is a max of $400/night with taxes (2 adults). I'm considering Bay Harbor & Coconut Bay or Kona Kai resort. Any thoughts on these or other suggestions?

Answer

Key Largo is a great stopover for a few nights on a Miami to Key West trip, especially if you want water activities and a relaxing atmosphere. For late April, the weather is typically warm and sunny, ideal for pool and beach activities.

Regarding the resorts you mentioned:

Bay Harbor & Coconut Bay: These are smaller boutique-style resorts known for good service and a relaxed vibe. They offer pool access and often provide kayak or paddleboard rentals. They are located near a few local restaurants, so dining options are convenient without needing to drive far.
Kona Kai Resort: Kona Kai is larger and offers a full-service resort experience with a pool, private beach area, and more extensive amenities. They also provide water sports rentals like paddleboards, kayaks, and snorkeling gear. It’s slightly more upscale and has on-site dining, though it may be at the top of your budget, depending on room type and taxes.

Other lodging options to consider within your budget:

Playa Largo Resort & Spa: Recently renovated, offers a large pool, beach access, and on-site restaurants. Known for excellent service and water activities.
Hampton Inn Key Largo: More budget-friendly, includes a pool, breakfast, and easy access to nearby restaurants and dive shops, though beach access is more limited.
Marina Del Mar Resort: Offers pool access and is close to the marina for paddleboarding or boat rentals. Simple but convenient location.

Tips for your stay:

Book early for late April, as rates can increase quickly during spring and Easter-related travel periods.
Confirm water activity rentals (paddleboards, kayaks) with the resort in advance to ensure availability.
Check whether parking is included or if there are additional fees, as this can impact overall cost.
Consider proximity to US-1 if you plan to drive down to Key West the following day—being close to the highway can save travel time.

In summary, both Bay Harbor & Coconut Bay and Kona Kai are excellent choices for a three-night stay. If you want a quieter, boutique experience with good access to local restaurants, Bay Harbor & Coconut Bay is great. If you prefer full resort amenities, pool, on-site dining, and beach/water sports, Kona Kai or Playa Largo would be ideal. All options should fall within your $400/night budget with careful booking.