3 nights dining islamorada
Arriving Sunday 11/19 staying at moorings . Struggling a bit for night one dining - was planning on chef Michael’s or Kaiyo but they are both closed Sunday.
Will book chef Michael’s one of the next two nights but looking for recommendations for a somewhat upscale Sunday option that takes reservations. Thanks
Islamorada has some excellent dining options, and even on a Sunday you can find upscale spots that take reservations. Since Chef Michael’s and Kaiyo are closed that day, here are some alternatives for your first night:
- Morada Bay Beach Café: A beautiful waterfront setting with a relaxed yet upscale vibe. They serve fresh seafood and Caribbean-inspired dishes. They take reservations and offer sunset views, which is perfect for your first night.
- Alabama Jack’s: More casual but well-known for fresh seafood and local flair. It’s not as formal as Chef Michael’s, but the quality and location on the water make it a good first-night choice.
- Lazy Days Restaurant: Located slightly south in Islamorada, it has a polished dining experience with great seafood and a view. They accept reservations and are known for attentive service.
- Oceanview Restaurants at Postcard Inn: The on-site restaurant offers an elevated menu and a scenic oceanfront setting, suitable for a Sunday night dinner.
Tips for your stay:
- Book reservations in advance, especially for Sundays in November, as Islamorada can get busy with tourists and locals.
- Consider timing your dinner to catch the sunset—most waterfront restaurants have excellent views.
- If you want to include a more relaxed night, some of the bars or casual eateries nearby offer seafood platters and cocktails without the formal vibe.
For your remaining two nights, securing a reservation at Chef Michael’s and Kaiyo is a great idea. Planning in advance will ensure you get the exact night you prefer. Overall, Sunday can be slightly trickier for dining, but the above options will give you a memorable start to your Islamorada trip.
More Florida Keys Travel Questions
- Budget lodging about half way from Miami to Key West
- Isla Bella or Tranquility Bay
- 2 night location - upper / mid keys
- Cuban sandwich/ Cuban coffee places Key Colony Beach
- Are there places to snorkel from the beach in the Keys?
- Day trip?
- Week in the Keys
- First time to area
- A few questions . . .
- Trip planning help please
- Florida keys with special needs
Popular Destinations
Popular Travel Questions
- Free shuttles from the port and hotel to sawgrass mills
- Chair and Umbrella Rental on the Beach
- Marriott's Oceana Palms or Palm Beach Marriott Singer Island
- Coral Gables or Coconut Grove 1st time
- After Yose backpacking, worth visiting Mammoth and Tahoe?
- 2 days in Guilin/Yangshuo: suggestions needed for hotel
- Recs for Sonoma wine tastings
- Drive to airport
- Rainy Day Trip Report March 30 through April 1
- Question about the 3 days visa
- Where to stay in summer--CB Mountain resort area or CB South
- Leshan area - 1 day or 2 days?