Cuban sandwich/ Cuban coffee places Key Colony Beach

Question

What’s your favorite place in or near Key Colony? Without a huge drive.

Answer

Key Colony Beach and the surrounding Middle Keys have a few great spots for authentic Cuban sandwiches and coffee without needing to drive far. The area is more low-key than Key West, so the best options are small, local cafés or sandwich shops that focus on fresh, flavorful food.

Recommended Cuban Sandwich & Coffee Spots Near Key Colony Beach

Midway Café & Coffee (Key Colony Beach area): A local favorite for breakfast and lunch, they serve Cuban sandwiches with fresh ingredients and strong, traditional Cuban coffee. The café has a casual, friendly vibe perfect for a quick bite.
Florida Keys Coffee Company (Marathon, ~5 min drive): Excellent for Cuban coffee, pastries, and sandwiches. Small, cozy spot with a focus on quality coffee and sandwiches made to order.
Glades Haven Café (Marathon, ~10 min drive): Serves Cuban-style sandwiches alongside breakfast and lunch options. Known for friendly service and a laid-back atmosphere.

Tips for Enjoying Cuban Cuisine in the Middle Keys

Most places are casual; it’s common to order at the counter and either eat inside or take your food to-go to enjoy on the waterfront.
Cuban coffee is very strong and often sweetened with sugar during brewing. Ask for a “cortadito” or “cafecito” if you want the authentic small, sweet espresso experience.
Timing matters—these spots are busiest during breakfast and lunch, so plan accordingly if you want to avoid a wait.

In summary, for Cuban sandwiches and coffee near Key Colony Beach, your best bets are small local cafés in Key Colony itself or a short drive into Marathon, offering fresh, authentic options without needing to go all the way to Key West.

Cuban sandwich/ Cuban coffee places Key Colony Beach

More Florida Keys Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions