Restaurant suggestions

Question

We will be visiting the island from Jan 16-22. Would love to hear your favorite restaurant suggestions for casual and a celebratory dinner. Thx

Answer

Amelia Island has a surprisingly strong dining scene for its size, with everything from relaxed beach cafés to upscale spots perfect for a birthday, anniversary, or special night out. Since you're visiting in mid-January, crowds are lighter and reservations are easier to get—which makes this a great time to explore the island’s food offerings.

Below is a detailed breakdown of both casual options and recommendations for a memorable celebratory dinner.

Top Casual Restaurants (Lunch or Relaxed Dinner)

Tasty’s Fresh Burgers & Fries – A fun, laid-back spot known for excellent burgers, shakes, and fast service. Great for families or a quick bite after exploring downtown Fernandina.
T-Rays Burger Station – A local favorite located in an old gas station. Famous for its Southern comfort food, fried shrimp, burgers, and friendly atmosphere.
Timoti’s Seafood Shak – Casual outdoor seating and some of the freshest fast-casual seafood on the island. Their shrimp baskets, poke bowls, and fish tacos are consistently popular.
Sliders Seaside Grill – Right on the beach with a large outdoor patio. Ideal for a relaxed meal with ocean views; great seafood, salads, and sandwiches.
The Happy Tomato Courtyard Café & BBQ – A charming courtyard setting with great pulled pork sandwiches, BBQ plates, and quick service.

Great Mid-Range Restaurants for a Nice But Not Formal Dinner

Espana Restaurant & Tapas – One of the most beloved restaurants on the island. Specializing in Portuguese and Spanish cuisine, including paella and excellent tapas. Welcoming vibe and reliably great food.
Cafe Karibo – Creative menu with a wide range of choices including seafood, sandwiches, salads, and global-influenced entrées. Beautiful patio and friendly service.
The Sandbar & Kitchen – Beachfront location with a huge menu, great wood-fired pizzas, and relaxing ocean views.

Best Options for a Celebratory or Special Occasion Dinner

Salt (at The Ritz-Carlton) – The most upscale restaurant on Amelia Island. A true fine-dining experience with seasonal tasting menus, exceptional seafood, and an elegant atmosphere. Perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, or any milestone.
Burlingame Restaurant – Modern American cuisine with a cozy yet upscale vibe. Great cocktails, beautiful plating, and a menu that carefully rotates with seasonal ingredients.
Joe’s 2nd Street Bistro – Warm, intimate, and consistently excellent. Popular dishes include fresh local seafood, steaks, and house-made desserts. A great romantic option without being overly formal.
David’s Restaurant & Lounge – A polished steakhouse and seafood restaurant known for excellent service and a more classic fine-dining feel. Good choice if someone in your group loves steaks or lobster.

Tips for January Dining

January is one of the quieter times on Amelia Island, but for the most popular restaurants—especially Salt, Burlingame, and Espana—making a reservation is still recommended for weekends. Weather can be cool but pleasant, so patios at places like Cafe Karibo and Timoti’s are often still enjoyable.

You’ll have a full week on the island, so you can enjoy a mix of laid-back beach meals and at least one great celebratory evening. With the options above, you’ll be covered for everything from casual lunches to memorable dinners.

Restaurant suggestions

More Amelia Island Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions