Worthwhile wine clubs

Question

Hello,

We are coming to Napa in May and starting to plan our out our winery visits, we are interested in Reds (more bold/tannic preferred, less interested in juicy/zins). It seems like there are some perks to being a member of wine clubs, including complementary tastings. Would I need to be a member of the wine club PRIOR to booking a tasting in order to get this benefit, or if I join after the tasting (when I confirm I enjoy the winery) would the tasting be compensated? Here is are top list of estates we are interested in visiting... Anyone a member and recommend?

- Duckhorn

- Far Niente (interested also in Nickel and Nickel and/or Chappelet)

- Mayacamas (maybe just Napa tasting room?)

- Hall

- Trefethen

- Quintessa

- AXR

- Caymus

- Paradigm

FWIW we collect (and drink :) ) wine as a bit of a hobby so we anticipate we will end up with several (12-24+) bottles of wine after this trip - whether we carry home or order via membership.

Answer

Napa Valley wine clubs can offer substantial perks, particularly if you plan to purchase wine or visit multiple wineries. Generally, complimentary tastings and other member benefits apply only to current members at the time of the tasting, not retroactively. This means that if you join a club after your initial visit, the tasting you did prior usually cannot be reimbursed.

For your May trip, here’s a breakdown and advice for your list of wineries:

Duckhorn: Known for bold Merlot and Cabernet Sauvignon. Wine club members often receive complimentary tastings and priority booking. You would need to be a member beforehand to enjoy tasting perks.
Far Niente / Nickel & Nickel / Chappellet: Far Niente focuses on Chardonnay and Cabernet; Nickel & Nickel specializes in single-vineyard Cabernet; Chappellet is known for elegant Cabs. Membership typically grants tasting benefits, exclusive releases, and discounts, but again, only for active members.
Mayacamas: A historic Napa property with very small production. Membership perks vary, and the tasting room in Napa may offer general tastings to non-members, but complimentary benefits are for members.
Hall: Offers bold reds and a range of art-filled tasting experiences. Membership includes complimentary tastings and discounts on purchases.
Trefethen: Known for rich Cabernets and Chardonnay. Club membership allows waived tasting fees and access to library wines.
Quintessa: Focuses on Bordeaux-style blends. Membership perks often include tastings and access to allocation wines. Must be a member to receive full benefits.
AXR: Smaller, boutique-focused winery with a range of bold reds. Check directly for membership benefits.
Caymus: Famous for Cabernet Sauvignon. Membership offers waived tastings, priority access, and discounts.
Paradigm: Another Cab-focused winery. Members enjoy waived tasting fees and priority allocations.

Tips for your trip:

If you plan to do multiple tastings in a single day and enjoy a bottle or two from each, it can be worthwhile to join clubs at your favorite wineries first. This can save on tasting fees and provide access to wines that may be difficult to find outside the club.
Many wineries allow you to join the club during your visit if you confirm you enjoy the wines, but typically, tasting perks are not retroactive.
Consider contacting the wineries in advance to ask about club benefits for visitors. Some may offer one-time complimentary tastings for first-time visitors who join immediately.
With your plan to collect 12–24 bottles, memberships can also make shipping and storage easier, especially for allocation wines that may not be sold at retail.

In summary, if tasting fees are a concern and you anticipate purchasing wine, it is generally best to join the wine clubs at the time of your visit to enjoy all member benefits.

Worthwhile wine clubs

More Napa Valley Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions