Amara Cay v. Reefhouse (Key Largo)

Question

Spring Break with the family. 2 kids, 4 and 7 years old. Any preference on properties? Life long keys visitors, but never these two properties.

Answer

For a family Spring Break stay with young kids in the Florida Keys, both Amara Cay and Reefhouse have their own strengths, and the choice depends on what type of experience you’re looking for.

Amara Cay

Located on Lower Matecumbe Key, it offers a more modern, resort-style experience.
Features include private cottages with multiple bedrooms, which is convenient for families with 2 kids.
On-site amenities often include a pool, beach access, and space for kids to play safely.
The property tends to be quieter and less “touristy,” which may appeal if you prefer a more relaxed environment.
Restaurants and groceries may require a short drive, so plan meals accordingly.

Reefhouse

Located in Key Largo, slightly farther north but still part of the Upper Keys.
Known for a laid-back, classic Keys vibe with oceanfront access and direct snorkeling or kayaking opportunities.
Accommodations are typically smaller, so ensure the unit you book comfortably fits your family.
On-site dining and casual bar areas are available, which can make evenings easier with kids.
Being in Key Largo, there are more nearby attractions such as the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary, which could be fun for short day trips.

Considerations for Families

Amara Cay may be better if you want more modern comfort, more privacy, and a dedicated pool area for the kids.
Reefhouse is ideal if your family loves being right on the water, snorkeling, and experiencing that classic Key Largo resort vibe.
Both properties are kid-friendly, but Amara Cay may feel slightly more spacious and self-contained for families with younger children.

Overall, if your goal is a relaxed, family-focused stay with amenities that accommodate small children, Amara Cay is likely the safer bet. Reefhouse is excellent if you prioritize water access and a social, active environment.

Amara Cay v. Reefhouse (Key Largo)

More Islamorada Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions