Where do the locals go for seafood dinner

Question

Just wondering if there are hidden gems on the island for seafood.

Answer

Anna Maria Island has a number of local favorites for fresh seafood that tend to be a bit off the beaten path compared to the more tourist-heavy restaurants. Locals often seek places with a relaxed vibe, fresh catches, and waterfront views without the high prices of the more popular spots.

Here are some of the hidden gems and local favorites for seafood dinner:

The Sandbar Restaurant: Located right on the beach at Bradenton Beach, the Sandbar is a local favorite for fresh seafood, sunsets, and a relaxed atmosphere. Their grouper and snapper dishes are highly recommended.
Beach Bistro: Situated on the south end of the island, the Beach Bistro offers a slightly more upscale dining experience with fresh, local seafood. The views of the water and the quality of the dishes make it popular among locals for special dinners.
Ginny’s & Jane E’s Cafe and Gift Store: While more casual and known for breakfast and lunch, Ginny’s sometimes offers evening seafood specials. It’s a local institution and worth checking for off-peak dinner options.
Star Fish Company: A classic seafood spot with a market feel where you can pick fresh catches. Located near the marina, it’s loved by locals for simple, fresh seafood meals.
Blue Marlin Grill: Near the Anna Maria city area, this smaller spot focuses on fresh seafood and relaxed dining, with dishes like fresh fish tacos and grilled seafood platters.

For a truly local experience, consider calling ahead to see if they have fresh catch specials or smaller seating areas. Many locals also recommend arriving before peak dinner hours, especially in high season, to enjoy a more relaxed meal without long waits.

Overall, Anna Maria Island offers a mix of casual and slightly upscale seafood experiences that highlight local catches and provide a laid-back island vibe perfect for a relaxed dinner.