Thurston Lava Tubes or Kula Kai caverns?

Question

We’re headed to volcanoes national Park for the day. Would you recommend that we spend our time stopping at Kula Kai caverns tubes on the way, or take our kids to the lava tube experience at Thurston? Thank you! They are 8 and 10. Today is the eight-year-old‘s birthday.

Answer

Great question — choosing between Thurston Lava Tube (Nāhuku) and Kula Kai Caverns really depends on what kind of cave experience you want — and what mood your kids are in (given ages 8 and 10, and that it’s your younger child’s birthday — happy birthday to them!). Both are on Hawai‘i Island (Big Island), but they offer somewhat different “vibes.” Below is a breakdown of the pros/cons to help you decide.

What Thurston Lava Tube offers

The trail to Thurston Lava Tube is very easy — a short forest walk from the parking (or from a nearby overlook), through lush rainforest, down a gentle descent, making it accessible even for younger kids.
Inside the tube you get a dramatic contrast: a cool, damp lava-carved cave where ancient molten lava once flowed (~500 years ago). Walking through a naturally formed lava tube is a rare experience.
The standard portion is well-lit (lights are on from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.), and the walk through the tube is not long — only about 600 ft. Including the rainforest walk, you can often finish in ~20–30 minutes (or a bit more, depending on how much you want to explore).
Because it’s inside Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park, visiting the tube is nicely combined with other volcanic park sights you’d likely want to see that day — steam vents, sulphur banks, crater-rim drives, etc.

Potential drawbacks for kids (and things to watch out for at Thurston)

The ground inside can be uneven, a bit slick, and the ceiling low in spots — you’ll want good shoes and watch your head.
Parking at the lava tube trailhead is limited — it tends to fill up quickly, especially mid-day. If you go, aim for early morning (or late afternoon) to avoid crowds and the parking hassle.
The “tunnel” is short and — while impressive — may feel brief to kids expecting a big “adventure cave.”

What Kula Kai Caverns offers

Kula Kai Caverns is a privately owned lava-tube cave system “on the way” between Kona / Ocean View and Volcanoes National Park. It offers guided tours — including a “lighted trail tour” that’s easy walk-in and kid-friendly, as well as more adventurous “wild tours” for older kids/adults.
The cave system is geologically “younger” (on a scale of lava tubes) — and the experience is a bit more “cave-exploration” compared to the more manicured park tube, which may feel more immersive for kids and adults who like spelunking.
Because tours are guided, there is likely to be more context: guides explain how the tubes formed, how ancient Hawaiians used them, and cave geology — which could make the visit more educational and memorable (especially for kids).
For a birthday — this might feel a bit more “special” and adventurous than a short walk-through, because caves can evoke a sense of mystery, discovery, and “real adventure.” If your child enjoys slightly bigger adventures, that could be a plus.

Potential drawbacks (or things to check) for Kula Kai Caverns

Access is by guided tour only, and you must reserve in advance. It's not a “drop-in” like Thurston — and the cave is on private land.
The environment can be more rugged: some tours include crawling, uneven floors, and darker passages. While the lighted-trail version is easier, you’ll still want sturdy shoes and maybe extra gear depending on the tour.
Because it’s farther away (depending on where you're coming from) than the easy-to-access Thurston, it could add more driving time or complicate scheduling if you want to see other parts of the volcano park the same day.

My recommendation for *your* situation (with kids 8 and 10, and a birthday):

Given that you’re visiting Volcanoes National Park on a day-trip: I lean toward recommending Thurston Lava Tube as the primary stop — especially if you haven’t done a cave/tube visit before. It’s easy to access, gentle enough for your 8-year-old, and a nice “taste” of underground volcanic geology without too much exertion or risk. Because it’s inside the park, you also get volcanic scenery before or after, making it a smooth, low-stress addition to your day.

If you have extra time (or maybe on another day), consider Kula Kai Caverns — but only if you’re up for a guided tour and want a more “adventurous cave-exploration” vibe. It could be a really fun bonus, especially if your kids are curious, love exploration, and don’t mind a little extra effort (and a likely reservation). It might be a great “special birthday” cave-adventure if done safely and with some planning.

Finally — if you go to Thurston, I’d suggest arriving early (before 9 a.m.) or later (after 4 p.m.) to avoid the parking crush. For Kula Kai — call ahead to book a lighted-trail tour (better for kids) rather than the more extreme “wild tours.”

Thurston Lava Tubes or Kula Kai caverns?

More Island of Hawaii Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions