Holland America day excursions vs: arranging on your own

Question

This is my 1st cruise on Holland America and my 1st cruise to Alaska. I have questions about using HA arranged excursions vs: making the arrangements on my own. Any information and advice will be greatly appreciated

Answer

When deciding between booking Holland America (HA) day excursions and arranging your own activities in Alaska, there are a number of factors to consider, including convenience, cost, flexibility, and experience quality. Many first-time Alaska cruisers weigh the pros and cons carefully because Alaska ports can be remote and the logistics can be tricky.

Advantages of Using Holland America Excursions

Guaranteed timing: HA excursions are scheduled to match the ship's arrival and departure times. If you book independently and the tour runs late, you risk missing the ship.
Convenience: HA handles transportation, tickets, guides, and sometimes meals. You simply show up at the designated meeting point.
Experienced guides: HA uses vetted local operators and guides who are familiar with the area and can provide insightful commentary and safety guidance.
Group safety and support: If anything goes wrong during the tour, the ship staff is aware and can assist, minimizing stress for first-time visitors.

Disadvantages of Using Holland America Excursions

Cost: HA excursions are generally more expensive than booking directly with local operators.
Less flexibility: Schedules are fixed and may not allow for extended exploration, personal pacing, or spontaneous activities.
Tourist crowd: Excursions can be large groups, which may feel less intimate or personalized.

Advantages of Arranging Your Own Excursions

Potentially lower cost: Many local tour operators offer similar activities at a reduced price.
Flexibility: You can choose your own timing, skip certain parts, or combine multiple activities in a way that suits your pace.
Smaller group experiences: Independent bookings often allow for smaller, more personalized tours and interaction with guides.

Disadvantages of Arranging Your Own Excursions

Timing risk: If the excursion runs late or transport is delayed, you may risk missing the ship departure. This is a major consideration in Alaska ports with limited transportation options.
Planning effort: You need to research reliable operators, confirm schedules, and possibly arrange your own transport from the dock to the activity.
Limited support: If an issue arises during your independent excursion, you have fewer resources compared to using the cruise line’s organized tours.

Tips for First-Time Alaska Cruisers

Consider a mix: For key excursions you really don’t want to risk missing (like glacier tours or whale watching), use HA excursions for peace of mind.
For flexible or lower-risk activities (short hikes, local shops, or sightseeing within town), arranging on your own can save money and provide a more relaxed experience.
Book any independent tour in advance, especially during peak season, and confirm transportation from the port to the tour location.
Ask for local recommendations or check recent reviews to ensure operators are reputable and experienced in Alaska conditions.

Overall, HA excursions offer security and convenience for first-time visitors, while independent arrangements offer flexibility and potential cost savings. Many travelers find a combination of both approaches works best.

Holland America day excursions vs: arranging on your own

More Alaska (AK) Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions