Nautilus vs Loews vs kimpton surfcomber

Question

Hello - I am going to south beach mid feb. I have stayed at the W hotel before, and a couple others. This time deciding between the nautilus vs kimpton surf comber vs Loews - love a lux hotel and a great beach with beach setup. which of the two do you recommend pls? either traveling solo or with 1 friend (no kids). I do love W/ Faena/ Edison but they are too expensive for my dates

Answer

For a mid-February stay in South Beach, both the Nautilus, Kimpton Surfcomber, and Loews offer strong luxury options, each with a distinct vibe. Since you’ve stayed at the W and other high-end properties, your expectations for design, beach access, and service are already high. Here’s a breakdown to help decide.

Nautilus by Arlo

The Nautilus is an Art Deco boutique hotel with a retro-modern aesthetic. It’s smaller than Loews or Surfcomber, giving it a more intimate feel. Beach setup is included with your stay, and the property emphasizes a quiet, stylish environment—good for solo travelers or friends looking to relax without a large party crowd.

Pros: Boutique feel, quiet and stylish, well-maintained beach cabanas, pool area is smaller but chic.
Cons: Fewer on-site amenities than larger resorts (limited restaurants and bars), less social scene if you’re looking to meet people.

Kimpton Surfcomber

The Surfcomber is also a boutique-style property but with a more modern, lively vibe. Its pool area is expansive and often the hub of activity, making it more social. The hotel offers daily beach setup and has an on-site bar and restaurant. It’s known for a friendly, energetic atmosphere, which is great if you enjoy a mix of relaxation and people-watching.

Pros: Larger pool area with social atmosphere, beachfront access with setup, daily curated events, trendy design.
Cons: Can feel busy and lively—less intimate than Nautilus, not as quiet if you want pure relaxation.

Loews Miami Beach

Loews is the largest of the three, offering full-scale luxury resort amenities. The beach is directly accessible with complimentary beach service, and the pools are expansive. The property is high-end, with multiple restaurants, a spa, and excellent service. It’s ideal if you want the full luxury resort experience, but it’s less boutique and more “classic resort” in feel.

Pros: Full-service luxury, multiple dining options, excellent beach service, large pool areas, consistent quality.
Cons: Larger property can feel less intimate, more crowded, less design-focused than boutique options.

Recommendation

For solo travel or with one friend and a preference for luxury, style, and a great beach:

If you want quiet, chic, and intimate: go with Nautilus.
If you want a lively, social, and trendy vibe while still enjoying luxury: Kimpton Surfcomber is likely the better choice.
If you want full resort amenities with consistent luxury and a reliable beach setup, but don’t mind a larger, busier environment: Loews is excellent.

Since you enjoy W, Faena, and Edison but need something less expensive, the Surfcomber is the closest in terms of energy and modern design, while Nautilus is more understated luxury. Loews offers the most amenities but is less “boutique chic.”

Overall, for mid-February South Beach, I’d lean toward Kimpton Surfcomber for a balance of luxury, beach access, and social atmosphere without the higher price of W or Faena.

Nautilus vs Loews vs kimpton surfcomber

More Miami Beach Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions