Updated Advice Request - Vacation Rental Location

Question

Hi All,

Thanks for your advice and assistance thus far! Our family of 4 is visiting DC for 5 days in March. I have identified rental properties at the following intersections, and would love your advice on location, safety, metro access, etc. We will not have a car and plan to do the general tourist things for our teens' first visit to the DC area. The properties are at the following cross-streets:

1. Third and A Streets (agent says it's NE DC and right near the Supreme Court)

2. 8th Street NE and Massachusetts Ave NE

3. Wisconsin Ave NW and O Street NW

Thank you!

Answer

Hi there,

Choosing the right location for a vacation rental in DC without a car is key for convenience, safety, and access to the main attractions, especially for a family with teens visiting for the first time. Here’s a breakdown of the three locations you mentioned:

1. Third and A Streets NE (near the Supreme Court)

This area is technically in the Capitol Hill neighborhood, which is central, historic, and very walkable. You’ll be close to the U.S. Capitol, Supreme Court, Library of Congress, and the National Mall.
Metro access: The Capitol South Metro station (Blue/Orange/Silver Lines) is within a short walk, which gives you easy access to other parts of DC.
Safety: Capitol Hill is generally safe, especially in the residential and government-adjacent areas. Standard city precautions apply.
Convenience: Restaurants, coffee shops, and small markets are nearby, plus you can walk to multiple Smithsonian museums and monuments.

2. 8th Street NE and Massachusetts Ave NE

This is further northeast, closer to NoMa and the northeastern edge of downtown. It’s a bit less central than Capitol Hill for walking to the National Mall.
Metro access: The NoMa-Gallaudet U Metro station (Red Line) is nearby, offering access to downtown, the National Mall, and attractions. However, you may need to take Metro or buses more frequently than staying near Capitol Hill.
Safety: This area has been revitalized and is generally safe, but it’s more commercial and industrial in parts, so it feels less residential than Capitol Hill.
Convenience: There are trendy restaurants and cafés, but fewer historic charm and immediate walking access to major monuments.

3. Wisconsin Ave NW and O Street NW

This location is in the Georgetown neighborhood, which is charming, walkable, and filled with shops, restaurants, and historic architecture. It’s a popular tourist area.
Metro access: Georgetown itself does not have a Metro station. You would rely on buses, scooters, or rideshares to get to central DC attractions like the National Mall, Smithsonian museums, and monuments.
Safety: Georgetown is very safe, upscale, and lively during the day. Evening safety is generally good, but streets can be quieter late at night.
Convenience: Great for exploring local shops, dining, and the waterfront. Less convenient for visiting National Mall monuments unless you plan to take public transport or rideshares frequently.

Recommendation:

If your goal is to maximize walking access to major tourist sites and have easy Metro access for exploring other parts of DC, the Third and A Streets NE (Capitol Hill) location is the most practical.
If you prefer a trendy, revitalized area and don’t mind using the Metro more often, the 8th Street NE option is workable.
If you want a historic, picturesque neighborhood with great local dining and shopping, and are okay with relying on buses/rideshares for the National Mall, Georgetown (Wisconsin Ave NW & O St NW) is ideal.

For a first-time family visit focused on DC’s main attractions and without a car, Capitol Hill provides the best combination of central location, safety, and Metro access.

Updated Advice Request - Vacation Rental Location

More Washington DC Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions