Coffee and Seafood places

Question

experts what are you top 5 seafood place in the siesta/Sarasota area? For Coffee Simons and Clever cup any other places? Thanks

Answer

Siesta Key and the surrounding Sarasota area have an excellent mix of relaxed beachy seafood spots and more upscale coastal restaurants. Coffee is also strong here, with several local roasters and indie cafés beyond Simons and Clever Cup. Below are well-known, consistently loved options.

Here are five popular and highly recommended seafood restaurants in the Siesta Key / Sarasota area—covering casual, waterfront, and more refined choices.

Big Water Fish Market (Siesta Key) – One of the top local favorites for ultra-fresh fish. You can dine in or buy fish from the market. Known for grouper sandwiches, fish tacos, and daily catch specials.
The Old Salty Dog (Siesta Key Village & City Island) – Casual, waterfront, classic Florida vibe. Great for peel-and-eat shrimp, fried seafood baskets, and watching boats go by.
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar (South Siesta) – Iconic spot, famous for award-winning New England clam chowder. Laid-back, great for families, and a solid variety of seafood plates.
Owen’s Fish Camp (Downtown Sarasota) – Rustic Southern-coastal style with consistently great seafood. Think oysters, low-country dishes, and fresh local catches. Popular and worth the wait.
Walt’s Fish Market (Sarasota) – A Sarasota institution. Seafood restaurant + fish market, so freshness is the star. The smoked fish dip and Gulf shrimp are must-tries.

As for coffee, since you already know Simons and Clever Cup (both excellent), here are several other strong local favorites worth visiting:

Perq Coffee Bar (South Sarasota) – Specialty craft coffee shop with single-origin pours, espresso, and an artisan feel.
Nekter Coffee & Juice Bar (near Siesta) – Smoothies and bowls too, but their coffee is well-liked for a healthier café vibe.
The Bean Coffeehouse (Gulf Gate) – A cozy neighborhood café with good espresso drinks and pastries; close to Siesta Key.
Project Coffee (Sarasota) – Vegan café with an excellent coffee program; minimalist, modern atmosphere.
Pastry Art Bakery Cafe (Downtown Sarasota) – A local staple for years; great for grabbing a coffee and pastry before exploring downtown.