Pros and Cons of lodging options

Question

We are 3 "older" sisters planning a trip to Key West in the fall and have been looking at lodging options. We will want to spend most of our time in Old Town. We have picked out La Concha, The Marker, Pier House and Ocean Key Resort. Pros, cons? Any other suggestions? We will definitely need parking. Included breakfast would be a plus but from what I've seen those are not complimentary. Thanks in advance.

Answer

It sounds like you're planning a wonderful trip to Key West with your sisters! Let's take a look at the four lodging options you've chosen and explore their pros and cons, as well as some alternatives. All of these places are in or very close to Old Town, so you’ll have easy access to the best attractions, restaurants, and shops in Key West. Here's a breakdown:

1. La Concha Hotel & Spa

Pros:

Located in the heart of Old Town, it’s a very central location for walking to Duval Street, Mallory Square, and the waterfront.
The rooftop pool and bar provide great views of the island and are a nice spot to relax after a day of sightseeing.
Elegant, historic property with modern amenities—ideal if you want a mix of classic charm with contemporary comforts.
On-site dining options and a fitness center.

Cons:

Parking can be challenging, with limited spaces and a parking fee, which could be a hassle given that you'll need parking.
No complimentary breakfast, but there is an on-site restaurant for meals.
Some guests mention that the hotel can be a bit noisy due to its central location, especially in the evenings.

2. The Marker Key West

Pros:

Located on the quiet side of Old Town, so it's a bit more peaceful than La Concha, but still within walking distance of the action.
Beautifully modern with a relaxed vibe—great for those who prefer newer accommodations with a boutique feel.
Several pools (including a stunning pool area), plus an on-site restaurant and bar.
Complimentary bike rentals are available, which can be a fun way to explore the island.

Cons:

Parking is available but at an additional charge, which can add up over the course of your stay.
Some guests feel the property is less "quaint" and more modern, which may not capture the full Old Town Key West experience.

3. Pier House Resort & Spa

Pros:

Beautiful oceanfront location with great views of the water and easy access to the beach.
Short walk to the best of Old Town—very convenient for sightseeing and dining.
On-site spa and private beach area, which are perfect for relaxing after a busy day.
Famous for its on-site restaurant, One Duval, which is highly rated for both food and drinks.

Cons:

Parking can be tricky and costly, with limited space available on-site.
No complimentary breakfast, though the restaurant on-site provides meals and breakfast options.
Since it’s an oceanfront property, it can be a bit pricier than some other Old Town options.

4. Ocean Key Resort & Spa

Pros:

Fantastic location at the edge of Mallory Square, so you’ll be close to the waterfront, shops, and restaurants.
Great amenities, including a lovely pool, spa, and an excellent restaurant with beautiful views.
Rooms have beautiful views, and some are directly overlooking the ocean or Mallory Square.
Very popular for its location and laid-back luxury vibe—perfect for those who want a high-end resort experience in Key West.

Cons:

Like the others, parking is not included and can be expensive in this part of Key West.
No complimentary breakfast, and the resort’s dining options can be pricey, though they offer great meals.
Because of its popularity, this resort can get busy, especially during peak seasons, which can impact the overall experience if you’re seeking a quieter stay.

Other Recommendations:

If you’re open to exploring other options, here are a few alternatives that might meet your needs:

Hemingway Home & Museum B&B: A charming and smaller B&B located near the Hemingway House. It offers more personalized service and a unique Key West experience.
Santa Maria Suites: A quiet, upscale resort with large suites, a relaxing pool area, and walking distance to Old Town. Perfect for those who want a more secluded, relaxing vibe.
Southernmost Beach Resort: Located at the quieter end of the island, this resort has direct beach access and great amenities, including a heated pool, but it’s still very close to all the attractions in Old Town.

Final Thoughts:

All of your choices are great, but the best option depends on your priorities. If you're looking for luxury and convenience in Old Town, Ocean Key Resort & Spa or Pier House would be ideal. If you prefer a more modern, boutique-style experience, The Marker is a solid choice. For a historic, central stay with some character, La Concha is a good pick, though it can be a bit noisier. Whatever you choose, enjoy your time in Key West—it’s truly a beautiful and unique destination!