Live Your Best Lives
  1. Travel FAQs
  2. United States
  3. Florida (FL)
  4. Florida Keys
  5. Key West

Super fresh seafood restaurant

Hello all!!!

I Know there are a lot of seafood restaurants in Florida Keys but could you recommend some that would have super fresh fishes or seafood, like catches of the day...

Thanks a lot!!!

Key West is famous for its fresh seafood, and several restaurants pride themselves on offering daily catches from local waters. For the freshest fish and seafood experience, you’ll want to focus on places that source directly from local fishermen or have a reputation for daily specials.

Highly recommended seafood spots:

  • Hogfish Bar & Grill: Located on Stock Island, just a short drive from Key West. Known for super fresh hogfish, snapper, and daily catches, served in a casual, local atmosphere.
  • Garbo’s Grill: A small food truck near Key West offering fresh seafood tacos, fish sandwiches, and daily specials depending on what’s caught that day.
  • Blue Heaven: While more famous for its brunch and quirky atmosphere, they offer fresh seafood dishes sourced locally and often have daily specials.
  • Conch Republic Seafood Company: Located at the historic seaport, this restaurant serves a variety of fresh seafood, often featuring catches of the day and local specialties like Key West pink shrimp.
  • Seaside Cafe & Raw Bar: Offers oysters, fresh fish, and daily catches. Often praised for its freshness and local sourcing.

Tips for the freshest experience:

  • Ask the server for the “catch of the day” or daily specials to ensure the seafood is as fresh as possible.
  • Consider visiting slightly off-peak hours for lunch or early dinner; some smaller local places sell out quickly once the daily catch is gone.
  • Walking or short driving distances work best; Key West is compact, and most of these spots are reachable without a long drive.
  • Support local fishermen: many of these restaurants highlight where their catch comes from, so you can enjoy truly local seafood.

Overall, Key West offers a range of options from casual food trucks to sit-down restaurants, all emphasizing fresh, locally sourced seafood. For the absolute freshest experience, heading to Hogfish Bar & Grill or Garbo’s Grill is highly recommended.

More Key West Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Republic

Popular Destinations

Getuo River Scenic Area
Silver Chain Falling Pond Waterfall
Quanzhou
Beijing Grand View Garden

Popular Travel Questions