Savannah vs Charleston vs Asheville

Question

Which would you recommend for an adventure seeking family of 5 (kids ages 20/14/12) for an 8 day vacation? We enjoy hiking, arts, rafting, biking, and history.

Answer

Each of the three destinations you mentioned—Savannah, Charleston, and Asheville—offers a unique experience, and all would provide opportunities for adventure-seeking families. Here's a comparison of the three locations based on your interests in hiking, arts, rafting, biking, and history:

1. Savannah

Known for its historic charm and Southern hospitality, Savannah is rich in history, culture, and beautiful outdoor spaces. It's ideal if you want a mix of urban and natural experiences, with plenty of time to explore history and arts in a relaxed, picturesque setting.

History: Savannah’s historic district is one of the best-preserved in the U.S. with beautiful squares, historic homes, and landmarks like the Cathedral of St. John the Baptist and Forsyth Park.
Outdoor Activities: While not known for high-energy adventure, there are some opportunities to enjoy nature. You can kayak or bike through scenic areas like the Savannah Riverfront and Bonaventure Cemetery, or take a riverboat tour.
Arts: The city has a vibrant arts scene, with galleries, museums (like the Telfair Museums), and theater performances.
Family-Friendly: Savannah’s cobblestone streets and historic sites are walkable and offer a laid-back atmosphere that may be perfect for a younger family looking for a relaxed pace with some exploration.

2. Charleston

Charleston, with its coastal beauty and historic significance, offers a fantastic balance of history, adventure, and outdoor activities. It's slightly more dynamic than Savannah, with more beaches and water-based activities to explore.

History: Charleston is steeped in history, especially regarding the Civil War and its role in the South's history. You can visit Fort Sumter, the Old Slave Mart Museum, and take walking tours of the historic district.
Outdoor Activities: Charleston offers kayaking and boating, and you can visit the beautiful beaches at Folly Beach or Sullivan's Island. You can also go on nature walks and bike rides at places like Waterfront Park.
Rafting and Biking: While Charleston is not famous for rafting, you can go paddleboarding or kayaking in the waterways. There are also opportunities for biking along the scenic coastal routes.
Arts: Charleston has a thriving arts scene with the Gibbes Museum of Art, the Spoleto Festival, and local galleries. It’s a perfect spot for those interested in exploring arts and culture.

3. Asheville

Asheville, located in the Blue Ridge Mountains, is your best bet if you're looking for more adventure, nature, and outdoor activities. It's an ideal choice if your family enjoys hiking, mountain biking, and exploring the great outdoors.

Hiking: Asheville is surrounded by the Pisgah National Forest and the Great Smoky Mountains National Park, offering an abundance of hiking trails, including the famous Blue Ridge Parkway. Trails like the Linville Gorge, Craggy Gardens, and Mount Mitchell will offer stunning views and a variety of difficulty levels.
Rafting: Asheville is known for whitewater rafting on the French Broad River, which offers some great thrills. It’s perfect for adventure-seekers looking to try something exciting on the water.
Biking: The area has excellent mountain biking trails, including the Tsali Recreation Area and Bent Creek Experimental Forest. The city itself also has bike-friendly routes.
Arts: Asheville has a very vibrant arts scene, with numerous galleries, the River Arts District, and a variety of public art displays throughout the city. It’s also known for its craft beer scene.
History: Asheville is known for its history, including the Biltmore Estate, America’s largest privately-owned home, which is a must-see for those interested in historical landmarks.

Summary of Recommendations:

If your family enjoys outdoor adventures like hiking, rafting, and biking in a mountainous setting, Asheville is the clear winner. It's perfect for active families seeking nature and exploration in the Blue Ridge Mountains.
If you're looking for a combination of history, arts, and a more relaxed pace with some outdoor activities, Charleston would be a great choice. It’s ideal for families who enjoy history, culture, and coastal landscapes.
If you want to explore a beautiful, historic Southern city with a laid-back atmosphere, Savannah offers a great mix of history, arts, and outdoor activities, though it may be less adventure-focused than Asheville or Charleston.

Each of these destinations is wonderful in its own way, but for a more adventure-filled trip with opportunities for hiking, rafting, and biking, Asheville would be the most suitable choice. Charleston and Savannah would be excellent for a more cultural and history-focused vacation.