Catalina Island Hotels

Question

Hello, a friend and I are going to Catalina for first time, mid October, two nights. Looking for quiet accommodations, four "bubbles" and up, 350 to 400 budget preferably. Would welcome suggestions. Thank you.

Answer

Great question! Catalina Island in mid-October is a lovely time to visit: quieter than peak season, with beautiful ocean views and mellow island vibes. Given your budget of $350–$400/night, here are some very good accommodation options that feel more intimate or “boutique,” plus a few tips.

Recommended Hotels on Catalina Island

Hotel Atwater (Avalon)
A historic, beautifully renovated hotel just a block from the beach and close to Avalon’s Tour Plaza. It has charm, good service, and island-deco touches. According to current listings, rooms can come in around $380/night at certain times.
The Avalon Hotel
A true boutique hotel in the heart of Avalon, with private balconies, a rooftop terrace, and cozy common areas. You’ll enjoy a relaxed, peaceful stay while being very close to shops and the waterfront.
Zane Grey Pueblo Hotel
Perched on a hillside overlooking Avalon Bay, this pueblo-style hotel offers dramatic views, a more secluded feel, and a rooftop lounge area. It’s often highlighted as one of Catalina’s most design-forward, peaceful stays.
Snug Harbor Inn
A Cape Cod–style inn right on Avalon Bay. Many rooms have fireplaces, jetted tubs, and ocean views. Guests also enjoy complimentary wine & cheese in the evening and a cozy, quiet environment.

Things to Consider in Your Choice

Location: Staying in Avalon is ideal for ease of access to restaurants, shops, and ferry terminals. All of the hotels above are walkable to town.
Views & Ambiance: If you want ocean views or a more “get away” feel, Zane Grey Pueblo or Snug Harbor are particularly strong picks. For being right in the heart of Avalon, The Avalon Hotel or Hotel Atwater are both great.
Rates & Availability: Mid-October might offer more favorable rates, but demand still exists—be sure to book soon.
Packages: Check ferry + hotel packages; sometimes they offer discounts that help stretch your budget.

Bottom line: Yes, you can definitely find quiet, “four-bubble” (or boutique-style) hotels on Catalina Island in your price range. My top recs based on your budget and desire for a peaceful, elevated stay would be Hotel Atwater or Zane Grey Pueblo—both offer charm, great views, and that relaxing island vibe.