Best seafood restaurant (esp. lobster)?

Question

First time in KW coming up next month. Any tips on which KW restaurant serves the best seafood, particularly lobster and/or conch?

Answer

Key West is famous for its fresh seafood, including lobster and conch, and offers a variety of restaurants ranging from casual to fine dining. For a first-time visit, you’ll want a combination of quality, atmosphere, and local flavor.

Top recommended seafood spots for lobster and conch:

Hogfish Bar & Grill: Located on Stock Island just outside Key West, this casual spot is known for its fresh seafood and authentic local vibe. The Hogfish sandwich and conch dishes are particularly popular.
A&B Lobster House: A classic waterfront restaurant on Key West Bight Marina offering fresh lobster, conch, and a variety of seafood. It’s a bit upscale but family-friendly and known for generous portions and quality.
Conch Republic Seafood Company: A lively, tourist-friendly option near Mallory Square. Excellent for conch fritters, conch chowder, and fresh fish. While the lobster menu isn’t as extensive, they sometimes offer daily specials featuring lobster.
Louie’s Backyard: For a fine dining experience, Louie’s Backyard offers upscale seafood with a view of the ocean. They are known for creative preparations of lobster and local fish, and the oceanfront deck is perfect for a sunset dinner.
DJ’s Clam Shack: Casual and well-loved for seafood on the go, offering lobster rolls, fried conch, and daily specials. It’s smaller and casual, ideal for a quick, tasty meal.

Additional tips:

Check menus online or call ahead, as lobster dishes can be seasonal or available as daily specials.
For the freshest experience, consider restaurants located on the water or marina areas, where seafood often comes directly from local catches.
Reservations are recommended for popular spots, especially during evenings and weekends.
Try conch in multiple preparations: fritters, chowder, and cracked conch to experience the range of flavors.

In summary, for lobster and conch in Key West, A&B Lobster House and Hogfish Bar & Grill are standout choices for quality and local flavor, while Louie’s Backyard offers a more upscale, scenic dining experience. Conch Republic Seafood Company and DJ’s Clam Shack provide fun, casual options that showcase Key West’s seafood culture.