Lincolnville or downtown area

Question

Never been to St. Augustine -

We like to be in walking distance of restaurants and attractions.

Answer

If your main goal in St. Augustine is to be within walking distance of restaurants, shops, and historic attractions, staying in either the downtown historic district or Lincolnville can work, but they offer slightly different vibes and conveniences.

Downtown Historic District:

This is the heart of St. Augustine and where most visitors prefer to stay if they want to be in the center of everything. You’ll be steps away from iconic attractions such as Castillo de San Marcos, the Lightner Museum, and St. George Street with its shops, cafes, and restaurants.

Pros: Extremely walkable, very close to historic sites, restaurants, and nightlife. Easy access to tours and trolley stops.
Cons: Can be crowded, especially on weekends or during holidays. Parking may be limited if you have a car.
Tips: Look for boutique inns, historic bed and breakfasts, or small hotels tucked within the district for charm and convenience.

Lincolnville:

Lincolnville is a historic neighborhood just north of downtown, known for its cultural heritage and quieter streets. It’s about a 10–15 minute walk to St. George Street and downtown attractions, so it’s slightly removed from the main tourist hustle but still very accessible.

Pros: Quieter and more residential than downtown, often more spacious or affordable accommodations. A few local eateries and coffee shops are nearby.
Cons: Slightly farther from the main attractions—walking 10–15 minutes to reach the heart of downtown.
Tips: Great for families or visitors who want a mix of local neighborhood feel and easy access to downtown.

Recommendation:

If being in the immediate walking radius of multiple restaurants and attractions is your top priority, the downtown historic district is the ideal choice. If you prefer a slightly quieter neighborhood with a local feel but don’t mind a short walk to attractions, Lincolnville is a very good option.

Lincolnville or downtown area

More St. Augustine Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions