Live Your Best Lives
  1. Travel FAQs
  2. United States
  3. Florida (FL)
  4. Florida Keys
  5. Key West

Renting through reality companies

What are the most reliable rental companies to use on Key West?

When it comes to renting a property in Key West, reliability is key, especially during peak travel seasons. Key West has a mix of local rental agencies and larger national companies, and choosing the right one can make a huge difference in terms of ease of check-in, quality of property, and customer service.

Recommended Reliable Rental Companies in Key West:

  • Key West Vacation Rentals: A locally owned agency with decades of experience in Key West. They handle everything from condos to full homes and are known for responsive customer service and accurate listings.
  • Mile Marker 0 Realty: Specializes in Key West properties and has a strong reputation for well-maintained homes and helpful staff. They offer flexible booking and clear policies.
  • Fodor’s / Vacasa Key West: Part of a national vacation rental network, Vacasa manages properties professionally, with 24/7 support and verified listings. Good if you want consistency and the ability to book online easily.
  • Island City Real Estate: Another local agency known for personalized service and a broad selection of homes and condos throughout the island.
  • Reef Realty: One of the older agencies in Key West, reputable for both sales and rentals. They have a mix of high-end homes and vacation condos, often with on-site staff to assist guests.

Tips for Renting in Key West:

  • Always read reviews and verify recent guest experiences; even reliable companies may have occasional issues.
  • Check if the company provides 24/7 guest support, especially for check-ins or emergency issues.
  • Confirm all fees upfront, including cleaning, parking, and local taxes, as Key West has specific vacation rental regulations.
  • Book early — Key West is very popular, and reputable rentals fill up fast, especially around holidays and spring break.
  • If you prefer extra security, consider companies that offer damage protection plans or full insurance options.

In general, local agencies like Key West Vacation Rentals and Mile Marker 0 Realty offer the best combination of personalized service and reliability. Larger networks like Vacasa are good if you want a more standardized booking experience with strong customer support.

More Key West Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

guest
spring

Popular Destinations

Boat-shaped thatched house in Baicha Village
Xinmin Little West Lake
Beijing Shengquan Mountain Scenic Area
The Art Institute of Chicago

Popular Travel Questions