Train or plane from Boston to NYC

Question

We are a family of three (two adults and a child aged 10) travelling from Boston to NYC on Sunday 16th August. Trying to decide the best mode of transportation between getting a train or flying.

Train is cheaper but will take longer (may be nice to see the scenery?!). My only other doubt about taking a train is luggage. We will have two large cases with us as well as normal carry on size bags/case. Details on Amtrak website indicate sizes for luggage which are smaller than our suitcases. Would we likely have an issue with large luggage and if so are we better flying?

If considering the train any thoughts on paying more for business class?

Many thanks in advance.

Answer

For your trip from Boston to NYC, both train and plane are viable options, each with its pros and cons. Here's a breakdown to help you decide:

Train (Amtrak):
- Cost: Generally, the train can be a cheaper option compared to flying, especially if you book early. However, it takes longer than flying (about 4 to 4.5 hours), so it depends on whether you mind the extra travel time.
- Luggage: Amtrak allows larger luggage, but it must be stored in the baggage car if it's over the standard carry-on size (28" x 22" x 14"). For your large cases, this may pose a problem since Amtrak's checked luggage rules are stricter. You might need to check your luggage in advance or at the station, which could be inconvenient if you want to keep your bags close. Carry-on bags should fit in the overhead compartment if within size limits. Check Amtrak's luggage policies in advance to see if your bags will be allowed without issue.
- Scenic Route: The train offers scenic views, especially as you leave Boston and travel through parts of New England. If you don't mind the extra time and want a more relaxed journey, this could be a great option.
- Comfort: Trains typically offer more space to stretch out, and you can move around more easily than on a plane. Business class provides additional amenities like more legroom, bigger seats, and sometimes access to a business lounge, making it more comfortable for the longer journey.
- Family Friendly: For a family of three, train travel can be comfortable. There’s room to move around and a little more flexibility, and kids typically enjoy the change in scenery and being able to walk around. However, it could be a longer journey for your child, so consider bringing snacks, games, or a tablet for entertainment.
Flight:
- Cost: Flights can sometimes be more expensive, but if you book early, you might find affordable options. A typical flight between Boston and NYC takes about 1 hour and 15 minutes, but you’ll need to account for the time it takes to get to and from the airport, security, boarding, and possible delays.
- Luggage: Flying typically involves stricter luggage rules, but your large cases should be fine as checked baggage. However, the baggage fees for larger suitcases (if they exceed the weight limit) could add to the cost of your flight.
- Time: Flying is the faster option in terms of actual travel time, but you’ll need to factor in the time spent at the airport (security, check-in, etc.), which can add an extra 1-2 hours to your journey, depending on the airport’s busy times.
- Convenience: With flying, you get a much faster journey, but there’s also more hustle (especially in busy airports). Depending on how much time you’re willing to spend at the airport and on the plane, it might feel less relaxing than a train ride.

Business Class on the Train: Opting for Business Class on the train gives you extra space, better seating, and sometimes access to premium lounges. If you’re looking for more comfort on the longer journey and are willing to pay a little extra, it could be a worthwhile upgrade. However, keep in mind that even Business Class on the train won’t make the trip as fast as flying.

Overall Recommendation: If you’re looking for a scenic, relaxed journey with more room to move around and are okay with the extra time, the train could be a great choice. Just be mindful of the luggage situation. If you need to prioritize time and convenience, flying will get you there faster, although it involves more logistics.

Whichever option you choose, both travel methods offer a unique experience. Safe travels!