Seeking hotel/resort recos

Question

Hello! I have been reading the forums and reviews but still a bit conflicted in where to book for a 9 night stay after Christmas through to early January. We are a family of four including two boys ages 13-15 (turning 16 when we are there). Looking for a resort that won't be jammed with people, with an relaxed Arizona feel, but enough good dining and enough activities that will allow us to stay onsite for the day - golf, sport, hike, swim while avoiding crowds. Our kids appreciate good food :) Any input welcome! We have considered the JW Marriott Camelback, Omni Montelucia, Sanctuary, and Westin Kierland but am not sure....

Answer

For a 9-night stay in Scottsdale with two teenage boys, you want a resort that balances relaxation, space, and plenty of activities onsite without feeling overcrowded, especially since this is during the post-Christmas/New Year peak season. Each of the properties you mentioned has its strengths, but there are some distinctions that may help you decide.

JW Marriott Camelback Inn

This resort has a classic Arizona ranch feel with spacious casitas and beautiful desert views. It offers multiple pools, a golf course, and fitness/wellness activities. The dining is solid, with a few options that are well-suited for families.

Pros:
- Large property, so crowds are spread out.
- Golf course onsite.
- Several pools, some quieter than others.
- Scenic desert hikes nearby without leaving property.
Cons:
- Can still be busy during peak holiday weeks.
- Some restaurants may require reservations well in advance.

Omni Montelucia

This is an upscale resort with Mediterranean architecture and luxury touches. It has multiple pools, a golf course, and a spa. It's slightly more boutique-feeling than JW Marriott, but it can be lively during holidays.

Pros:
- Beautiful design and desert setting.
- Multiple pools including family-friendly areas.
- Good on-site dining options.
- Golf course nearby.
Cons:
- Holiday crowds can make pools and restaurants busy.
- Not as spread out as JW Marriott; walking around property is easier but less secluded.

Sanctuary on Camelback

This is a smaller, more exclusive property with a boutique feel. It is quiet, luxurious, and has incredible views, but it is less activity-oriented for teens. Pools are smaller, and the focus is on relaxation and fine dining.

Pros:
- Very quiet and upscale.
- Stunning desert and mountain views.
- Excellent dining and spa experience.
Cons:
- Limited activities onsite for teens.
- Smaller pools and fewer family-friendly amenities.

Westin Kierland

This resort is excellent for families, with a large water park-style pool area, plenty of sports options, and accessible golf. It tends to feel more lively, which may appeal to teens looking for activities without leaving the resort.

Pros:
- Great family amenities: large pool, slides, and sports courts.
- Onsite golf and tennis.
- Multiple dining options, casual and upscale.
- Spacious grounds, so even during holidays, the pool area can feel spread out.
Cons:
- More of a “resort vibe” rather than secluded desert retreat.
- Can be busy during peak holiday periods.

Summary & Recommendations:

If your priority is family-friendly amenities, teens’ activities, and a more casual resort vibe: Westin Kierland is a strong choice.
If you want a classic Arizona experience with golf, pools, and slightly more space between guests: JW Marriott Camelback Inn is excellent.
If you want luxury, privacy, and quiet, but your teens may need to find off-property activities: Sanctuary is ideal.
If you want a balance of luxury and activity, but slightly smaller property than JW: Omni Montelucia is a good compromise.

Considering your desire to avoid crowds while keeping teens entertained and having good dining onsite, I would rank your top choices for a family of four as: 1) Westin Kierland, 2) JW Marriott Camelback, 3) Omni Montelucia, 4) Sanctuary.